timothée chalamet said "never say never" to playing elio again. then he said "but." we heard the but.
Chalamet at the Call Me by Your Name press conference, Berlinale 2017. Photo: Maximilian Bühn, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
via Vanity Fair, with The A.V. Club and PinkNews.
Three words and an ellipsis. That is how long the dream lived.
In his Vanity Fair cover story, published Nov. 17, Timothée Chalamet was asked whether he would ever go back to Elio, the role in Call Me by Your Name that the magazine calls "his star turn." His answer opened "A great question. Never say never, but," and then, after the pause every gay in America felt in their chest, he said he had "grown up with the mindset that you don't really go near something that is so near and dear to people."
The writer, Mark Guiducci, did the translation for all of us in the very next line: "So, that's a no."
Then Chalamet threw the gays a bone, or at least a director. "Now, to work with Luca again? In a heartbeat." That would be Luca Guadagnino, who is having a year, and whose new film Artificial comes up earlier in the same profile, when Chalamet says the first chapters of a book he is reading track its plot. (We reviewed Artificial, for the record, and we have notes.)
The A.V. Club landed where Guiducci did and headlined it as Chalamet being "probably all set" on another round. PinkNews went with "never say never" and kept the door open a crack, which is the more fun reading and also the less accurate one.
Here is the thing, though. The answer is correct. Call Me by Your Name works because it ends: a fireplace, a long take, a boy crying while the credits roll. Some summers are supposed to stay summers. He has Dune: Part Three coming, an Oscar campaign for Marty Supreme behind him this year, and he has spent this fall fielding everything from a cover story to Megyn Kelly's theories about his sexuality. Declining to reheat the most beloved queer romance of his career is the least controversial thing he has said all season.
We will be over here, in the heartbeat part.




