The Gay Agendaa man set fire to the room four lesbians shared in buenos aires. three died. a court just called it hate, a first for argentina.
The Gay Agenda · by · November 19, 2026

a man set fire to the room four lesbians shared in buenos aires. three died. a court just called it hate, a first for argentina.

The lesbian pride flag, for illustration. Image: Мистер Либертарианец, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

via Ámbito, LatFem and PinkNews.

Pamela Cobas, Mercedes Roxana Figueroa and Andrea Amarante were lesbians, and on Wednesday a court in Buenos Aires finally wrote down that this is why they died.

Oral Criminal and Correctional Court No. 5 sentenced Justo Fernando Barrientos to life in prison on Nov. 18 for the fire that killed the three women and injured a fourth, Sofía Castro Riglos, Ámbito reported. Judges Adrián Pérez Lance, Juan Manuel Grangeat and Cinthia Oberlander found him guilty of aggravated homicide, with the aggravating factors including hatred of the victims' sexual orientation and the use of a method that put others in danger, according to Ámbito and LatFem. Both outlets describe it as the first time an Argentine court has recognized that motive in the killing of lesbian women.

what happened in barracas

In the early hours of May 6, 2024, Barrientos opened the door of the room the four women shared in a residential hotel on Olavarría Street in the Barracas neighborhood, where he also lived, and threw in a burning object, according to the investigation as Ámbito summarized it. Witnesses at trial said he had harassed and insulted the women over their sexuality before the attack.

Pamela died that day. Roxana died two days later. Andrea died on May 12, PinkNews and Ámbito reported. Sofía, Andrea's partner, survived with burns to her arms, hands and face. LatFem, which covered all 19 days of hearings, reported that Pamela and Roxana had been together for at least six years, and that Andrea and Sofía had come to Buenos Aires from Neuquén after living on the street, where shelters would not let them stay together.

Prosecutor Juan Manuel Fernández Buzzi had asked for life. The defense asked for an acquittal, arguing the evidence did not prove Barrientos started the fire, and Barrientos told the court he felt innocent, PinkNews reported.

what the ruling left out

The court did not apply the gender-violence aggravating factor that the prosecution and the victims' lawyers had asked for, LatFem reported, and Amnesty International Argentina criticized that gap while calling the verdict a historic precedent, per PinkNews. The court also denied reparations for Sofía, who was not in the room for the verdict. Her lawyer, Luciana Sánchez, told LatFem that a sentence is not the same thing as repair, and that the result left them wanting more.

In her closing argument, Sánchez had drawn a straight line from the fire to anti-LGBTQ rhetoric from President Javier Milei and figures around him, LatFem reported. That argument is why activists insisted on the word "lesbicide" in the first place: not a neighbor's quarrel, but something the culture around it made easier.

On Argentine X the line of the night was "fue lesbicidio," it was lesbicide. Left-wing politician Myriam Bregman, in a post with more than 1,200 likes, called the ruling a historic precedent won by the organizing of families, survivors and activists.

Hundreds of people waited outside in pouring rain to hear the sentence, LatFem reported, holding signs with three first names on them. The court will publish its full reasoning on Feb. 19, 2027.