a reagan-appointed judge read trump's rules for hiv clinics and called them "loathing." the clinics can say trans again.
The John Joseph Moakley U.S. Courthouse in Boston, for illustration. Photo: NewtonCourt, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
via Reuters and LGBTQ Nation.
"Animus, loathing, and discrimination." Three nouns, and a federal judge chose all of them on purpose.
U.S. District Judge William Young in Boston ruled on Thursday that the Trump administration cannot stop health care providers funded by the Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program from acknowledging that their transgender patients are transgender, or from giving them gender-affirming care, Reuters and LGBTQ Nation reported. The decision runs 165 pages. Young was appointed by Ronald Reagan, which is the detail every press release on the right is going to skip.
what the ruling did
Ryan White is the program Congress created in 1990 to give medical care to low-income and uninsured people living with HIV. Beginning in March, the agency that runs it, the Health Resources and Services Administration, attached new conditions to the grants to carry out Trump's executive order recognizing only two sexes, Reuters reported. Providers had to make sure the money supported work using "sex-based definitions grounded in biological reality" and not "social or medical experimentation," according to the lawsuit, which both outlets quote.
Medical groups including the American Academy of HIV Medicine sued, represented by Lambda Legal. Young sided with them. He found the conditions were built to suppress what the administration saw as "dangerous ideas," which violates the First Amendment, by punishing doctors for acknowledging that trans people exist and for using their patients' pronouns. He also found the rules discriminated on the basis of sex in violation of the Fifth Amendment, Reuters reported.
The conditions "are based in animus, loathing, and discrimination," Young wrote. They "do not stand for justice," he went on, adding, "in fact, they defy it. They are contrary to the laws of this nation and cannot continue to stand."
why the pronoun part matters
It sounds petty because it was petty. A clinic treating someone with HIV was being told that calling that patient by her name could cost it federal money. HIV care works when people keep showing up, and people stop showing up to places that treat them like a problem. Jose Abrigo, the Lambda Legal lawyer on the case, called the ruling a "sweeping merits victory for the plaintiffs," in a statement both outlets quoted.
The Department of Health and Human Services did not immediately respond to Reuters. An appeal would be no surprise. It has been a rough week for this particular argument in court, though: this week the D.C. Circuit blocked the Pentagon from discharging 27 trans troops too.
Somewhere in Boston a clerk just finished proofreading 165 pages. We hope someone bought them lunch.




