Pride in Progressa bakery fought for nine years over one plain white cake for two brides. it ends with $12,000 and a civil rights class every year. should've just sold the cake.
Pride in Progress · by · November 19, 2026

a bakery fought for nine years over one plain white cake for two brides. it ends with $12,000 and a civil rights class every year. should've just sold the cake.

Photo, for illustration: Kimberly Vardeman, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

via KGET and 23ABC News

The cake in question was white. It was not custom. It was, as California's civil rights director put it in 2025, "a predesigned, multipurpose cake," per KGET. And it took nine years, a trial, an appeal and two trips to supreme courts to settle whether Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio could buy one for their wedding.

They can. Well, the next couple can.

what tastries agreed to

Tastries, the Bakersfield bakery owned by Cathy Miller, reached a settlement on Friday with the state Civil Rights Department, which announced it Monday, KGET reports. Under it, the bakery will provide non-customized products, cakes included, to all customers regardless of sexual orientation or other protected characteristics. It will attend civil rights training from the department every year, post the department's notices on civil rights protections, notify the department of any discrimination complaints, report on its compliance annually, and pay $12,000 in damages and fees, according to KGET and 23ABC.

"In California, we don't turn people away because of who they love or where they come from," department director Kevin Kish said in the release, as quoted by KGET.

Annual civil rights training. For a bakery. We would pay to watch that PowerPoint.

how a cake became a nine-year case

In 2017 Tastries refused to sell the couple a cake for their wedding; according to the state, the bakery had a policy against selling cakes for celebrations of same-sex unions, 23ABC reports. The couple complained to the department, which sued in 2018. Miller's lawyers at the Thomas More Society argued she is a devout Christian and that baking the cake would violate her religious beliefs, KGET reports.

A Kern County judge sided with Miller in 2022. In February 2025 a state appeals court reversed, calling the refusal "intentional discrimination," per KGET. The California Supreme Court declined to review it, and in December 2025 so did the U.S. Supreme Court, KGET reported at the time. "This isn't the result I prayed for, but I am sure God will use this for His glory," Miller said then.

Neither station carried a comment from Miller on the settlement. Nine years of litigation over a cake she could have sold in nine minutes, and it ends where every customer in California already stood: you sell the cake.