Pride in Progresswisconsin's oldest gay bar closed with no last dance. the state just gave it a plaque. we're crying on wells street.
Pride in Progress · by · November 20, 2026

wisconsin's oldest gay bar closed with no last dance. the state just gave it a plaque. we're crying on wells street.

Milwaukee City Hall, for illustration. Photo: Michael Barera, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

via Urban Milwaukee and the Milwaukee Independent.

In 2008 a local historian walked into This Is It! to interview its founder for the bar's 40th anniversary. June Brehm looked at him and said, "I know you. I took your fake ID away once." She had, in 1988, when he was 15, Michail Takach told the Milwaukee Independent.

On Thursday Takach, now president of the Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project, stood outside her old door at 418 E. Wells St. while the state unveiled a historical marker in her honor. Gov. Tony Evers made a surprise appearance, Urban Milwaukee reported.

Brehm, a married mother of two, opened the bar on Aug. 1, 1968, nearly a year before Stonewall, so her gay friends had somewhere to drink without being humiliated. Warned about the consequences, she said, "Let them come for me. I'm doing this because it needs to be done," according to a History Project board member quoted by the Independent. Her granddaughter, Sarah Freiheit, added that Brehm called herself "the gay queen" and "wore her leather pants."

The bar ran 57 years and closed abruptly in March 2025, under owners George Schneider and Brian Firkus, the man you know as Trixie Mattel, who became a co-owner in 2021, Urban Milwaukee and PinkNews reported at the time. (Yes, that Trixie.) "This was a bar that never got a goodbye, never got a farewell party, never had a grand finale or last dance," Takach told Urban Milwaukee. "So what I feel today is closure."

The History Project paid for the marker with community donations, the Independent reported. Wisconsin Historical Society CEO Christian Ă˜verland called it the state's 650th marker and only its second about LGBTQ history. A separate city landmark nomination was dropped last year at the property owner's request, Urban Milwaukee reported, so the plaque may outlast the rainbow facade it sits in front of.

Alderman Peter Burgelis, the first openly gay man elected to the Milwaukee Common Council, said it best: "Take a look at that door. For 57 years, people walked through it." Even the street was closed for the ceremony, which, given that the owners blamed months of Wells Street construction in part for the closure, is the most Milwaukee punchline imaginable.