an ohio senator ended her conversion therapy testimony by reading lady gaga into the record. nobody had a single question.
Photo: Lady Gaga on the Born This Way Ball tour, Milan, 2012. cesareb from Italy, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
via The Buckeye Flame, which filmed the hearing
The whole hearing took less time than the song.
On Tuesday, Nov. 10, Ohio Senate Minority Leader Nickie Antonio and Sen. Beth Liston, both Democrats, gave sponsor testimony to the Senate Health Committee on Senate Bill 71, which would bar licensed physicians, psychologists, counselors, social workers and advanced practice nurses from practicing conversion therapy on a minor. The Buckeye Flame timed the hearing at under four minutes.
Liston did the medicine. "We have over 70 years of data telling us this hurts children," she said. "Let's protect them instead." Antonio did the closer.
what she read the committee
"I think these lyrics by Lady Gaga of all people give the best rationale for why conversion therapy is not only damaging to individuals who are exposed to it, but also demonstrates that people are who they are regardless of external pressures," she said, and then read the chorus of "Born This Way" to the committee, the part about God not making mistakes and being on the right track, baby. You know the one. Then she thanked the room and offered to take questions.
"Any questions from the committee?" came the call from the dais. Nothing. "Seeing none," and that was that.
why the silence matters
That silence is the actual news, and it is not a good sign. Ohio Senate rules guarantee a hearing to any bill introduced by April of an even-numbered year, the Buckeye Flame notes, which is how SB 71 got one at all. This is the fourth time Ohio lawmakers have considered a ban like it. No second hearing is scheduled. Fifteen Ohio municipalities already ban the practice for minors on their own.
Meanwhile the Republican majority is working the other direction. A section of House Bill 693, which would protect parents who reject their trans children, would bar state agencies from "stating or suggesting" that treatment refusing to affirm a trans child can be called "conversion therapy." So one bill would ban the practice and the other would ban the word for it. Only one of them has the votes. Elsewhere, Switzerland just backed a national ban.
If the committee will not hear the science, Antonio gave them the version they might actually hum on the drive home.




