In Memoriama reagan judge struck down two gay marriage bans and ended the argument with "go figure." he has died at 87.
In Memoriam · by · November 15, 2026

a reagan judge struck down two gay marriage bans and ended the argument with "go figure." he has died at 87.

Photo: Richard Posner at Harvard University. chensiyuan, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

via the Associated Press, the University of Chicago Law School and ABC7 Chicago

"Go figure." Two words, in a federal appeals court opinion, about whether gay people in Wisconsin and Indiana could get married. Most judges do not write like that. Richard Posner did, constantly.

Posner died on Nov. 10, the University of Chicago Law School said. He was 87. Ronald Reagan appointed him to the Chicago-based Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals in 1981, and he was a senior lecturer at the University of Chicago Law School, which called him a pioneer of law and economics. His 1973 textbook, Economic Analysis of Law, is still in print, the AP notes.

the go figure ruling

On Sept. 4, 2014, writing for a unanimous three-judge panel, Posner struck down the same-sex marriage bans in Wisconsin and Indiana, as NPR's Nina Totenberg reported that day. The states had argued that marriage exists to steady heterosexual couples who have children by accident. Posner took that argument and simply described it back to them.

"Heterosexuals get drunk and pregnant, producing unwanted children; their reward is to be allowed to marry," he wrote. "Homosexual couples do not produce unwanted children; their reward is to be denied the right to marry. Go figure."

When the states leaned on tradition, he pointed out, as the AP recounts, that there are also "bad traditions," and listed "cannibalism, foot-binding, and suttee." It was not a close call, and he declined to pretend it was.

Three years later he was part of the ruling that found the 1964 Civil Rights Act also barred discrimination against LGBTQ workers. He wrote that he could not see why firing a woman for being a lesbian was any less sex discrimination than firing her for being a woman.

who he was

He was a Reagan appointee and an economist at heart, and he got to these cases by asking whether the states' arguments made sense, not through any movement. That is what made the marriage opinion sting: the case against us did not survive a judge who simply insisted it add up.

Adam Chilton, the law school's dean, called him "prolific, influential, and endlessly curious," and said, "He was a giant whose influence on our legal system, the field of law and economics, and on our law school cannot be overstated." His survivors include his son, Eric Posner, a professor at the same law school.

The ruling read like a man who had run out of patience with bad arguments. We will keep quoting it.